Listening enlightened?
This article was a bit more confusing than the last few, since there were a lot of different terms that were thrown around, such as intertextuality and subjectivity. First, the discussion of musical meaning came about; then came talk of interpretation of this meaning, both in terms of direct imitation and subjective thought. The link between context and text seems to me a little unclear, as the author never explains the text as the music. The reasoned, fictive, subjective accounts of the reception of Haydn at the end of the article are an interesting leap into the eighteenth century mindset, using the philosophy described in the first half of the reading. The question that is pressing on my mind concerns the “multiplicity” of interpretations, which is discussed often: If listening became so subjective, so open to many interpretations, how was the concept of listening constrained before the enlightenment? Was free interpretation allowed previously? There isn’t much in the text that describes the previous state of musical interpretation, and I think this would be important in postulating that there was a change in the perception of the music of Haydn and Mozart.
Tuesday, April 28, 2009
Interpretation as a One-to-One Function (Simon, 4/28)
Mike, thank you for explaining what semiotic means. I was confused.
Korsyn's metaphor of nesting dolls that encapsulate each other reminded me of a very similar concept in real number analysis: that of boundedness. If some set, whether finite or infinite, is bounded, then there exists a disc that has all the points of the set interior to it. No matter how large one makes the disc, the infinite nature of human thought means that there is still more “stuff” outside of the disc than inside. This means, among other things, that no matter how broad a piece of music is, there exists some element outside the boundary, some idea that cannot be derived from the music. Is this a problem? Furthermore, if the set of possible interpretations is bounded, then no amount of patching or adding interpretations to the piece will ever encompass all ideas and feelings the human mind can evoke. Is this a problem?
Lowe throws around a few words that attempt to explain how music is distributed and processed. Expression, imitation, and suggestion are all used by 18th century thinkers to describe the role music plays in regard to nature. Are these simply gradients of relation? Or does each different term have some correspondence with a particular way music is processed by a listener?
Despite a disassociation with both the subject and musical content of “With Horns and With Hounds,” the merchant draws a quick connection between this folk melody and the Haydn's first movement. This, and the similar connection made by the noble, indicate that there may be stronger correlation between content and interpretation than previously argued. Certainly, the two attentive listeners feel different emotions towards the hunt, but it is the hunt that they both immediately focus on. Does this indicate a circumscribing or limitation of interpretation?
Korsyn's metaphor of nesting dolls that encapsulate each other reminded me of a very similar concept in real number analysis: that of boundedness. If some set, whether finite or infinite, is bounded, then there exists a disc that has all the points of the set interior to it. No matter how large one makes the disc, the infinite nature of human thought means that there is still more “stuff” outside of the disc than inside. This means, among other things, that no matter how broad a piece of music is, there exists some element outside the boundary, some idea that cannot be derived from the music. Is this a problem? Furthermore, if the set of possible interpretations is bounded, then no amount of patching or adding interpretations to the piece will ever encompass all ideas and feelings the human mind can evoke. Is this a problem?
Lowe throws around a few words that attempt to explain how music is distributed and processed. Expression, imitation, and suggestion are all used by 18th century thinkers to describe the role music plays in regard to nature. Are these simply gradients of relation? Or does each different term have some correspondence with a particular way music is processed by a listener?
Despite a disassociation with both the subject and musical content of “With Horns and With Hounds,” the merchant draws a quick connection between this folk melody and the Haydn's first movement. This, and the similar connection made by the noble, indicate that there may be stronger correlation between content and interpretation than previously argued. Certainly, the two attentive listeners feel different emotions towards the hunt, but it is the hunt that they both immediately focus on. Does this indicate a circumscribing or limitation of interpretation?
Yumi: Program music vs listeners' perception
The assertion that music should imitate proves that the eighteenth-century composers and philosophers considered instrumental music as program music. According to the Harvard Dictionary of Music, the program music “attempts to express or depict one or more nonmusical ideas, images, or events.” However, Lowe suggests that the “programs” evoked from music are not only created by composers, but listeners’ perception also has a big role in it. Taking the same motif, a brass fanfare for example, different listeners will have different reactions or emotions to it. Servants may feel inferiority and need to respect, on the contrary to a ruler who may feel admiration for himself by his people. As Lowe says, the hearings of musical works “are grounded in the social, cultural and political realities of listeners’ respective “privileged” historical listening contexts” (97) and thus, expressions “are in themselves neither natural nor artificial; they are but signs” (72). There’s so much a composer can express through compositional techniques, and everything is depends on listeners’ ability to think in his mind in order for music to have meaning.
Later in this article, Lowe takes three different fictional characters listening to Haydn symphony No. 88 for their first time to explain the centrality of intertextuality and subjectivity. Three different characters of different sex, status, and culture like/dislike the different parts of the symphony, and have different interpretations of the same measure. Lowe conclude this discourse by asserting that “to construct meaning freely assures the instrumental music of the late eighteenth century an ability to generate pleasure, aesthetic and otherwise, among its diversity of listeners.” (98)
1. Do you think the eighteenth-century music is program music? Although the concept of program music was not firmly established yet at that time, composers imitated nature through composition. On the contrary, do you still call it program music even though listeners perceive the music in different way than composers intended?
2. If all the instrumental music was subjective, how do you think composers strived to evoke a certain emotion? Do you think there was any technique composers used? or was it impossible to compose any music which everyone perceive it in the same way?
Later in this article, Lowe takes three different fictional characters listening to Haydn symphony No. 88 for their first time to explain the centrality of intertextuality and subjectivity. Three different characters of different sex, status, and culture like/dislike the different parts of the symphony, and have different interpretations of the same measure. Lowe conclude this discourse by asserting that “to construct meaning freely assures the instrumental music of the late eighteenth century an ability to generate pleasure, aesthetic and otherwise, among its diversity of listeners.” (98)
1. Do you think the eighteenth-century music is program music? Although the concept of program music was not firmly established yet at that time, composers imitated nature through composition. On the contrary, do you still call it program music even though listeners perceive the music in different way than composers intended?
2. If all the instrumental music was subjective, how do you think composers strived to evoke a certain emotion? Do you think there was any technique composers used? or was it impossible to compose any music which everyone perceive it in the same way?
Monday, April 27, 2009
While many theories have been developed about how music effects a listener’s emotions, these theories are inconclusive and only can provide a prospective to how this emotion might be evoked in a given work. It is interesting to consider, however, that these theories are not new ideas in music. While many of them may have been developed and recorded within a more modern period, it was an idea of the enlightenment to inspire this type of thought in philosophers and composers of the time. Wouldn’t it be likely that each of these composers had their own philosophies on how emotion in the listener is evoked? I think the answer to this is, likely. Perhaps it was one composer’s perspective that music could only transfer emotion by means of imitation. This composition would be inherently different from a composition of another composer, which embeds ideas of emotion portrayed though association (historical, social, etc…). It is also possible that some composers of this time period composed using both compositional techniques. Regardless of which compositional style was used, it is important to consider that many of the works composed in this era were written with a certain emotion, or certain emotions, in mind. As listeners, we of course are given the right to choose how we listen to a given work, but I also think it is a valid to state that listening in the 21st century is a very different endeavor than listening of the 18th century. This is primarily due to the fact that musical associations have greatly changed over the last 200+ years. For instance, a highly chromatic piece of music in the 18th century, which might have been seen as shocking in the 1700’s might seem very consonant and in turn, not provide the same effect to the listener of today. This dilemma brings up a much larger (and harder to answer) question pertaining to the emotions portrayed in music. Is it at all important to consider the original emotional intentions in a given piece of music? Because so much of musical interpretation is a subjective act, would taking these intentions into consideration be stripping music of natural ability to evoke a wide variety of emotions from listener to listener, or would this contextual intersubjectivity be a what the composer originally intended? How do you think the theorists discussed in our reading would have felt about these issues?
One argument of this article is that emotion in music is largely subjective. Do you believe this to be true? Why or why not?
In the 20th century, composers used many other means to portray emotions within music. What are some other techniques which can be used to portray emotion in music? If you don’t know any techniques used in the 20th century, invent some of your own ideas.
Most would argue that it was not a goal of music predating the enlightenment to evoke emotions in the listener though a composer’s music. Based on your own observations vs. what we have learned in this class, do you believe this to be true? Why would emotion by means of association not be a characteristic of pre-enlightened music?
One argument of this article is that emotion in music is largely subjective. Do you believe this to be true? Why or why not?
In the 20th century, composers used many other means to portray emotions within music. What are some other techniques which can be used to portray emotion in music? If you don’t know any techniques used in the 20th century, invent some of your own ideas.
Most would argue that it was not a goal of music predating the enlightenment to evoke emotions in the listener though a composer’s music. Based on your own observations vs. what we have learned in this class, do you believe this to be true? Why would emotion by means of association not be a characteristic of pre-enlightened music?
Historical Fiction (Mike)
The first thing that I did after reading this article was look up the word semiotics. According to the Merriam-Webster online dictionary semiotics is “a general philosophical theory of signs and symbols that deals especially with their function in both artificially constructed and natural languages and comprises syntactics, semantics, and pragmatics”. In the case of this article, Lowe uses the term semiotics to refer the arguments for and against the idea of specific meanings being written into the music of the late 18th century. In the first half of the article, Lowe proceeds through a history of the discussion on how music affects both the senses and the mind separately and in tandem. He begins with Du Bos who believes that nature must be imitated in order to arouse the passions in a listener. He also states that in order for music to be successfully imitative, it must arouse both the passions and the mind. He proceeds in this vein through Diderot who says that he never liked a symphony that he couldn’t interpret (invest with specific images) and Kant who suggested that we listen to music for physical rather than mental rewards. Finally, he references Umberto Eco who raises the complicated issue of what context should be considered and limited in the interpretation of a work and fervently states that a single correct interpretation of a work is a repressive idea. Though he also points out that saying a work doesn’t have a single correct interpretation does not mean that there are not incorrect interpretations. This all is intended to function as a safety measure against false interpretations that come out of uninformed discussion.
After this discussion, Lowe moves on to discuss how well-informed fiction can be a powerful tool in historical writing. In demonstration of this principle and the crux of the article, he combines this position with Eco’s and writes three historically informed though fictional accounts of a first (and only) hearing of Haydn’s op. 88 from the point of view of an Austrian nobleman, English banker, and a wealthy woman in post-revolutionary Paris who has recently come into her money. The accounts are interesting for many reasons, but the one that sticks out most to me is how the imitations in the music are interpreted by the listeners. When we have previously read and discussed the idea of imitation in 18th century music it has seemed like the imitation written into the music was interpreted in the same way by the majority of the audience present. This is true for the first tier of interpretation by the characters in that most of the time the characters interpret the musical signals to represent the same things, but in each case their experiences with the ideas that these musical ideas represent cause them to follow different thought processes and experience different emotions than their counterparts. In light of all of this discussion, all of the theories presented in the beginning of the article, and you previous experience with historical methods and 18th century imitation, does this fictionalized approach seem like a valid way to address imitation in 18th century music?
Lowe makes a big deal out of the fact that this will likely be the only time that her characters will hear this symphony performed, do you think that the practice of imitation is used in part to give the audience something to connect with since a deeper study of the music is inconvenient or all together impossible?
What do you think about the idea of Handel being part of the cannon of the Academy of Ancient music in the late 18th century?
After this discussion, Lowe moves on to discuss how well-informed fiction can be a powerful tool in historical writing. In demonstration of this principle and the crux of the article, he combines this position with Eco’s and writes three historically informed though fictional accounts of a first (and only) hearing of Haydn’s op. 88 from the point of view of an Austrian nobleman, English banker, and a wealthy woman in post-revolutionary Paris who has recently come into her money. The accounts are interesting for many reasons, but the one that sticks out most to me is how the imitations in the music are interpreted by the listeners. When we have previously read and discussed the idea of imitation in 18th century music it has seemed like the imitation written into the music was interpreted in the same way by the majority of the audience present. This is true for the first tier of interpretation by the characters in that most of the time the characters interpret the musical signals to represent the same things, but in each case their experiences with the ideas that these musical ideas represent cause them to follow different thought processes and experience different emotions than their counterparts. In light of all of this discussion, all of the theories presented in the beginning of the article, and you previous experience with historical methods and 18th century imitation, does this fictionalized approach seem like a valid way to address imitation in 18th century music?
Lowe makes a big deal out of the fact that this will likely be the only time that her characters will hear this symphony performed, do you think that the practice of imitation is used in part to give the audience something to connect with since a deeper study of the music is inconvenient or all together impossible?
What do you think about the idea of Handel being part of the cannon of the Academy of Ancient music in the late 18th century?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
